v21 EAP: Can't establish HA - Interface Port "Source: Port1"

LHerzog 7 days ago

I cannot establish HA between two brand new XGS136 SFOS 21

Error: Can't establish HA. Both devices must use the same HA passphrase and dedicated HA link IP addresses that belong to the same network.

Network Settings are correct.

But on the to-be-Aux node, the Interface I choose Port10 looks strange.

What does Source: Port1 mean? Never seen that.

Both machines have been reimaged with USB stick before HA Setup.

Btw. the Aux machine did also not automatically register to Central using ZeroTouch Setup.

One other strange observation: the Aux node has a completely different PSU that the other. I have never seen such PSU. It looks some kind of cheap quality.

Parents

0 LuCar Toni 7 days ago

Did you work with Backup / Restore here?

SFOSv21.0 uses a different ordering. Instead of ordering the interfaces in the GUI via Port1-10, it uses the Names to order.

The source simply shows the real backend hardware.

So here, Port1 and Port10 are used.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel
0 LHerzog 7 days ago in reply to LuCar Toni

yes Port 1 and Port 10. Thats my config default. I did not use backups.

Maybe the ZeroTouch misconfigured something. I have now factory reset it and try again.

But again, Port10,11 and 12 look not normal. See here:

Screenshot from after Factory reset. I can now re-image it again - but why should it change?

XGS136_XN02_SFOS 21.0.0 EAP1-Build152# psql -U nobody -d corporate -c "select *

Breakout Port? Is that a bridge config?

from tblinterface;"
interface | enabled | linktype | mtu | mss | interface_speed |    overridemac    | zoneid | parentinterface | memberof | name   | fecmode | autoneg | breakout | breakoutroot | interface_status
-----------+---------+----------+------+------+-----------------+-------------------+--------+-----------------+----------+---------+---------+---------+----------+--------------+------------------
Port1     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |      1 |                 |          | Port1   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port2     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |      2 |                 |          | Port2   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
GuestAP   |       0 |       21 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            | f2:03:33:77:b9:82 |      7 |                 |          | GuestAP | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port3     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port3   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port4     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port4   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
   |              |                100 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port5   | fec_off |       1 |       --More--
Port6     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port6   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port7     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port7   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port8     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port8   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF2    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | PortF2 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF1    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | PortF1 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port9     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port9   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port12    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port12 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port3        |                1
    |        |                 |          | Port10 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port1        |                1
Port11    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port11 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port2        |                1
(15 rows)
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel
0 LHerzog 7 days ago in reply to LHerzog

same after re-image. That device has some problems or was used in some strange tests before shipped to us

XGS136_XN02_SFOS 21.0.0 EAP1-Build152# psql -U nobody -d corporate -c "select * from tblinterface;"
interface | enabled | linktype | mtu | mss | interface_speed |    overridemac    | zoneid | parentinterface | memberof | name   | fecmode | autoneg | breakout | breakoutroot | interface_status
-----------+---------+----------+------+------+-----------------+-------------------+--------+-----------------+----------+---------+---------+---------+----------+--------------+------------------
Port2     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |      2 |                 |          | Port2   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
GuestAP   |       0 |       21 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            | f2:66:d6:f4:d7:6d |      7 |                 |          | GuestAP | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port3     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port3   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port4     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port4   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port5     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port5   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port6     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port6   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port7     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port7   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port8     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port8   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF2    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | PortF2 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF1    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | PortF1 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port9     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port9   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port12    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port12 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port3        |                1
Port10    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port10 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port1        |                1
Port11    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port11 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port2        |                1
Port1     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |      1 |                 |          | Port1   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
(15 rows)
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel
0 LHerzog 7 days ago in reply to LHerzog

that's the expected output, taken from the other node.

XGS136_XN02_SFOS 21.0.0 EAP1-Build152# psql -U nobody -d corporate -c "select *
from tblinterface;"
interface | enabled | linktype | mtu | mss | interface_speed | overridemac | zoneid | parentinterface | memberof | name   | fecmode | autoneg | breakout | breakoutroot | interface_status
-----------+---------+----------+------+------+-----------------+-------------+--------+-----------------+----------+---------+---------+---------+----------+--------------+------------------
Port3     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | Port3   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port4     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | Port4   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port5     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | Port5   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port6     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | Port6   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port7     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | Port7   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port8     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | Port8   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF2    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | PortF2 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF1    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | PortF1 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port9     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | Port9   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port12    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | Port12 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port11    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |        |                 |          | Port11 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port1     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |      1 |                 |          | Port1   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port2     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |      2 |                 |          | Port2   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port10    |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |             |      3 |                 |          | HA-Link | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
(14 rows)
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel
0 LuCar Toni 7 days ago in reply to LHerzog

Apparently, could we RMA this device?

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel
0 LHerzog 7 days ago in reply to LuCar Toni

thats what I'm also thinking of. First I'm now trying a GA iso re-image.
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel
0 LHerzog 7 days ago in reply to LHerzog

unfortunately this is also with GA SFOS. So I need to RMA it.

XGS136_XN02_SFOS 20.0.2 MR-2-Build378# psql -U nobody -d corporate -c "select * from tblinterface;"
interface | enabled | linktype | mtu | mss | interface_speed |    overridemac    | zoneid | parentinterface | memberof | name   | fecmode | autoneg | breakout | breakoutroot | interface_status
-----------+---------+----------+------+------+-----------------+-------------------+--------+-----------------+----------+---------+---------+---------+----------+--------------+------------------
Port1     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |      1 |                 |          | Port1   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port2     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |      2 |                 |          | Port2   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
GuestAP   |       0 |       21 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            | f2:66:d6:f4:d7:6d |      7 |                 |          | GuestAP | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port3     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port3   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port4     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port4   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port5     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port5   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port6     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port6   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port7     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port7   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port8     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port8   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF2    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | PortF2 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF1    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | PortF1 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port9     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port9   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port12    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port12 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port3        |                1
Port10    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port10 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port1        |                1
Port11    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port11 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port2        |                1
(15 rows)
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel

Reply

0 LHerzog 7 days ago in reply to LHerzog

unfortunately this is also with GA SFOS. So I need to RMA it.

XGS136_XN02_SFOS 20.0.2 MR-2-Build378# psql -U nobody -d corporate -c "select * from tblinterface;"
interface | enabled | linktype | mtu | mss | interface_speed |    overridemac    | zoneid | parentinterface | memberof | name   | fecmode | autoneg | breakout | breakoutroot | interface_status
-----------+---------+----------+------+------+-----------------+-------------------+--------+-----------------+----------+---------+---------+---------+----------+--------------+------------------
Port1     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |      1 |                 |          | Port1   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port2     |       0 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |      2 |                 |          | Port2   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
GuestAP   |       0 |       21 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            | f2:66:d6:f4:d7:6d |      7 |                 |          | GuestAP | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port3     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port3   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port4     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port4   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port5     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port5   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port6     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port6   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port7     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port7   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port8     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port8   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF2    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | PortF2 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
PortF1    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | PortF1 | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port9     |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port9   | fec_off |       1 |          |              |                1
Port12    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port12 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port3        |                1
Port10    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port10 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port1        |                1
Port11    |       1 |        0 | 1500 | 1460 | auto            |                   |        |                 |          | Port11 | fec_off |       1 |          | Port2        |                1
(15 rows)
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel

Children

0 LHerzog 7 days ago in reply to LHerzog

Support Case: 01927300
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel
0 LHerzog 1 day ago in reply to LHerzog

LuCar Toni can you move this to the normal Firewall Forum as it is not specific to v21 (EAP). That machine has the same issue with v20 SFOS.

btw. RMA should be on the way
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Verify Answer

Cancel