Web policy block page not loading

When trying to access a website that is being blocked by a web policy, the Sophos page that typically loads saying the site is blocked is not loading. Tried this in both Safari and Chrome. I'm just getting the error (in Safari):

Safari Can't Open the Page

Safari can't open the page: "172.16.16.16:8090/ips/block/webcat....<truncated>" because the server where this page is located isn't responding.

Similar error in Chrome (e.g. "This site can't be reached").