Interface Routing Works From UTM out, not to UTM

Hey Everyone, 

     I'm trying to setup a static route to another network in the same location. I'm not looking for LAN 1 to use LAN 2 as a gateway (or vice versa)

Essentially this is the setup. 

Lan 1 (FiOS with Netgear X10) 

192.168.1.x

Lan 2 (UTM-9)

192.168.2.x

I setup static routing on the netgear (screenshot: https://www.dropbox.com/s/64phpik7j7gslfw/Screenshot%202018-03-04%2010.51.18.png?dl=0)

Here is the LAN setup (with RIP info) (Screenshot: https://www.dropbox.com/s/99hxkoe2y990uz0/Screenshot%202018-03-04%2010.53.47.png?dl=0)

I setup static routing on the UTM-9 (screenshot:  https://www.dropbox.com/s/8hyfzj69i2gdngn/Screenshot%202018-03-04%2010.52.51.png?dl=0)

On Lan 2, I can connect to Lan 1's router. 

On Lan 1, I cannot connect to any asset on Lan 2. 

Here is the only firewall entry made: (screenshot: https://www.dropbox.com/s/7e7z12s3i18gr9a/Screenshot%202018-03-04%2010.56.09.png?dl=0)

NAT Masquerading rules *Note I've tried it enabled and disabled to no avail* (Screenshot: https://www.dropbox.com/s/b9qpiuvyyud9b3u/Screenshot%202018-03-04%2010.56.39.png?dl=0)

Clearly I am missing something but don't know what that may be. Any help and guidance is super appreciated in advance. 

Thanks