Port forwarding to Additional IP

I have 5 external IP's from my ISP. I have setup the .158 as the main IP address.

I have added .156 en .157 as additional IP's (Interfaces - Additional Address). I have forwarded HTTPS from the main address to my internal server. Now i am trying to also forward HTTPS to .157, i get the error:

"The NAT rule object cannot use service group objects for the destination service attribute"

So my question is, is it not possible to forward HTTPS (or any other port) to an additional IP when the same port is forwarded from the main external IP address?